Gone Girl by Daniel Kelly
My Old Lady by Jay Seaver
Boxer's Omen, The by Jay Seaver
Come Drink with Me by Jay Seaver
Fearless Hyena, The by Jay Seaver
Treatment, The by Jay Seaver
Waste Land (2014) by Jay Seaver
I Am Trash by Jay Seaver
Equalizer, The by Brett Gallman
I Am Here (2014/II) by Jay Seaver
Equalizer, The by Peter Sobczynski
Boxtrolls, The by Peter Sobczynski
Man From Reno by Jay Seaver
Star Packer, The by Charles Tatum
Walk Among the Tombstones, A by Charles Tatum
Automata by Jay Seaver
Everly by Jay Seaver
Stranger, The (2014) by Jay Seaver
Tale of the Princess Kaguya, The by Jay Seaver
'71 by Daniel Kelly
subscribe to this feed
|Short Stuff: The 2012 Oscar-nominated Animated Shorts
|by Jay Seaver
Animated shorts tend to take the "short" part seriously, and as a result, the "Animation" package is seriously filled out - not just by segments with "hosts" William Joyce and Brandon Oldenburg, who won last year's Oscar in the category for "The Fantastic Flying Books of Mr. Morris Lessmore" (and which seems more like a repurposed interview than hosting, as it never actually references any of the included movies), but with three "Highly Commended" honorable mentions, one of which takes up roughly a third of the package's run time. Fortunately, there is truth in the idea that good things come in small packages; although some of these move very quickly, those tend to pack a lot of wit and invention into their short length - especially considering that none of the nominees feature dialogue!
For example, "The Longest Daycare", a Simpsons short starring baby Maggie, is only five minutes long, but generally doesn't go more than a few seconds before a new gag comes along, and once things get going, it's probably pretty exciting for the youngsters who were half its target audience when it played in front of the latest Ice Age movie last summer, with the jokes related to how Maggie gets the short end of the stick at the "Ayn Rand School for Tots" aimed at the adults in the audience.
A Hans Zimmer score helps with that, and it's just one example of how director David Silverman, who previously directed The Simpsons Movie and many episodes of the series, has some nice studio resources at his disposal. The picture is bright and colorful with smooth motion, and the credits indicate it was originally produced in 3D. It's a very capable short, generally pretty funny; exactly the sort of thing one would want to attach to the front of a celebrity-voiced franchise movie.
"Adam and Dog", meanwhile, is the opposite in many ways: Relative newcomer Minkyu Lee's colors may be lush where the detailed backgrounds are concerned, but the title characters are simple browns and flesh tones, making them a bit smaller than the world they inhabit. Writer/director Minkyu Lee also doesn't mind letting scenes stretch out for a bit to give a setting a certain feel - this pre-historic forest is idyllic, but also features just enough danger for the dog and the human he meets to come together so that the former becomes the latter's Best Friend.
Given the title, it's not hard to figure out where Lee is going with this; an Eve does eventually show up and complicate things, with Genesis eventually being more directly referenced as opposed to alluded to. Lee makes the transition there nicely, maintaining the dog's point of view throughout but changing the color palette and atmosphere enough that the attentive viewer can see what happens. It's a nifty trick, one which makes up for how the pacing can sometimes be a little too relaxed.
Where Lee may not have a long filmography, PES (the nom de film of Adam Pesapane) certainly does; anyone who has seen an animation program at a film festival or a touring show like "Spike & Mike" or "The Animation Show" has likely seen one or more of his quick stop-motion bits which recast familiar objects in new contexts. That's what "Fresh Guacamole" offers, starting with avocados in the shape of hand grenades and going on from there. Fans have seen similar things before - it's a follow-up to "Western Spaghetti" - but the fact that PES has been nominated for an Oscar will surely make them smile.
There are actually voices credited for Timothy Rechart's "Head Over Heels", but I don't believe they say anything particularly articulate. That's sort of the point, after all - that after decades of marriage, Walter and Madge may live in the same house but don't communicate much, living separate lives to the extent that each seems to live on the ceiling relative to the other. It's an arresting visual that I suspect works better here than in upcoming feature Upside Down, as it's allowed to be almost purely metaphorical rather than something that has to make sense physically.
It makes for a fun little movie, too, as Walter attempts to win her back and both must figure out what to do when their house that was spinning in space makes landfall. The stop-motion animation is very well-done indeed, and Reckart and cinematographer Chloe Thomson make good use of their ability to shift perspectives - I'll bet a lot of live-action filmmakers must envy their ability to literally turn their set upside down, although the limited space to work with these miniatures in an environment that frequently needs a full complement of walls and floors/ceilings must make up for it. They certainly come up with a cleverly-constructed world that they use for humor and pathos; it's one of the strongest from a strong field.
But is it strong enough to overcome "Paperman"? John Kahrs's seven-minute short got a lot of attention when it was released to theaters attached to Wreck-It Ralph; I'm sure a few people said it was worth the price of a ticket on its own (though I imagine most eventually said staying for the feature was far from a hardship). The funny thing is, it really is that good, and I actually found myself enjoying it more on a second viewing.
Maybe it's because I wasn't seeing it in 3D this time (along with the different context), because where I marveled at some of the technical feats before - it really is an amazing example of computer-rendered imagery managing the expressiveness of hand-drawn while still retaining its solidity and working in the third dimension - this time had me amazed by just how well everything worked together: The style, the simple storytelling, the Christope Beck score, the almost purely visual bits. Indeed, some of the things I found a bit of a weakness the first time are among my favorites now - the way the paper airplanes dance when they first start moving with a will of their own just strikes me as so early Disney, like they wouldn't be out of place in Fantasia or a Silly Symphonies short. That encapsulation of the company's entire history is kind of wonderful, and part of the reason I wouldn't bet against Kahrs coming home with a statuette in a few weeks.
All five of the nominees are quite worthy, although it's a little bit easier this year to see why the three "Highly Commended" shorts also included with the program don't quite make the cut. "Abiogenesis" by Richard Mans, for instance, is gorgeous - its visuals of a robot terraforming ship arriving on a barren planet and kickstarting the processes of life are beautifully rendered and frequently very creative - but it's undeniably chilly; the robots are such pure automatons that the audience can't help but feel the lack of humanity, especially after all the expressive characters in the previous shorts. As awe-inspiring a sequence as the five-minute short is, it feels like it should be part of a longer piece so that it can have some context within a story. Somebody get Mans signed to do an animated sci-fi feature so that can happen.
The next honorable mention, Leo Verrier's "Dripped", also suffers a bit in context; it looks like it was created to primarily be viewed on computer screens; blown up to be shown on the multiplex's main screen, the visuals seem kind of low-res. It's also weird, featuring an art thief who steals paintings to eat them, taking on their traits as he does so, and not knowing what to do when the manhunt makes it hard to replenish his supply. I think Verrier's onto a clever idea here - literalizing the idea of consuming art, letting it change you and influence your own process of creation without necessarily reproducing it - but it's not communicated very clearly, and his own cartoony style does not always mesh well with the artists he references.
The finale short in the program - and by far the longest, at 27 minutes - is "The Gruffalo's Child", a sequel to a nominee from two years ago, "The Gruffalo" (reviewed here, as part of the 2011 package), and like its predecessor, it is a solid piece of work with a very nice voice cast (Helena Bonham-Carter, Robbie Coltrane, Rob Brydon, John Hurt, Tom Wilkinson, and James Corden all resume their roles, with Shirley Henderson joining as the title character). It's even got a clever idea for a twist, with the Mouse being described as a terrifying creature of legend to the young Gruffalo, rather than the other way around as in the first short. The air is let out a little, though, as the audience members already know what a mouse is (heck, they likely know this mouse), so it's a bit difficult to build up the same kind of danger and surprise.
The three honorable mentions are all still worth seeing - check ShortsHD's website for more information on the easiest way for you to see them in your area, whether in theaters, via iTunes, or on demand - though, and in their being very good but not quite brilliant manage to emphasize what a strong group the nominees are. If I were voting for the award - or just entering a contest like our Oscar Pick' Em - the part of me that wants to recognize impressive young new artists would be pulled toward "Adam and Dog" or "Head Over Heels", but "Paperman" is probably too good to deny, and I would not be surprised at all if the Academy went the same way.
One more thing worth noting: While the package is rated PG-13 and I would generally have little problem recommending it for all-ages (and kids will really enjoy several of the shorts), there is nudity in both "Adam and Dog" and "Dripped". It's not meant to be titillating and seems harmless to me (said the guy with no kids), but don't come crying to me if you freak out when watching with the little ones.
link directly to this feature at http://www.efilmcritic.com/feature.php?feature=3512
originally posted: 02/10/13 15:15:44
last updated: 02/10/13 15:31:30