More in-depth film festival coverage than any other website!
Home Reviews  Articles  Release Dates Coming Soon  DVD  Top 20s Criticwatch  Search
Public Forums  Festival Coverage  Contests About 
Advertisement

Overall Rating
2.76

Awesome: 2.33%
Worth A Look: 13.95%
Average54.65%
Pretty Bad: 15.12%
Total Crap: 13.95%

8 reviews, 38 user ratings


Latest Reviews

Raja Natwarlal by Jay Seaver

Search for Weng Weng, The by Jay Seaver

Creep (2014) by Jay Seaver

Kundo: Age of the Rampant by Jay Seaver

Guardian (2014) by Jay Seaver

As Above, So Below by Jay Seaver

November Man, The by Jay Seaver

Hana-Dama: The Origins by Jay Seaver

Creeping Garden, The by Jay Seaver

Seventh Code by Jay Seaver

subscribe to this feed


Assault on Precinct 13 (2005)
[AllPosters.com] Buy posters from this movie
by Rob Gonsalves

"Decent if uninspired remake."
3 stars

Back there in 1976, two years before unleashing 'Halloween' on an unsuspecting world, John Carpenter established his bad-ass street cred with the low-budget 'Assault on Precinct 13.' A tip of the hat to 'Rio Bravo,' the movie worked minimalist wonders with its stark, no-nonsense premise of cops and criminals banding together to hold off a gang siege.

The 2005 remake is okay for what it is, but it's the work of people trying a little too consciously to be Carpenter-esque -- most of the film is painted in varying tones of gun-metal blue, for instance, just like an early Carpenter flick. Still, it's not a work of sacrilege, either, especially considering that Carpenter's original -- reportedly not among his favorites (like many directors looking back on early work, he can only see the rookie stumbles) -- was itself a loose remake of Howard Hawks' 1959 Western, and Carpenter himself sort of remade it as the atrocious Ghosts of Mars.

Ethan Hawke, as cadaverous as ever (get the man a sandwich), leads the new cast as tormented Detroit desk cop Jake Roenick, once a hotshot undercover narc before a bust went bad. He's the one presiding over the soon-to-be-closed Precinct 13 on New Year's Eve, during a hellacious snowstorm that forces a bus full of convicts to dump its surly cargo into 13's cells. Along with seasoned Irish cop Jasper (Brian Dennehy, a welcome sight) and hot-to-trot secretary Iris (Drea de Matteo), Jake grudgingly takes in the convicts, including notorious gangster Marion Bishop (Laurence Fishburne, who must've found the weight Hawke lost), who's the target of corrupt cops (led by a clenched Gabriel Byrne) who want to whack him before he testifies and implicates them.

James DeMonaco's script is amusingly blunt about its character set-up, but also forgetful; at one point a convict (Ja Rule) actually introduces himself as a Libra, then pegs someone else as an Aries, but then never waxes astrological again. The usefulness of one character, Jake's shrink Alex Sabian (who implausibly gets stranded at the precinct), is limited to the fact that she's played by Maria Bello, who along with Drea de Matteo gets some of the typical John Carpenter femaleness (smart, scared but tough) onto the screen. Indeed, a lot of the characters here seem to be written (and acted) in homage to Carpenter, which may explain why, despite the change in premise and location, this Assault never quite feels like its own film. (Carpenter's tribute to Rio Bravo, on the other hand, declared its own personality loud and clear.) It's decent imitation J.C., I suppose -- an homage twice removed.

Carpenter, I think, would have been more interested in the convicts than in Jake's crisis of confidence. John Leguizamo, acting like Steve Buscemi channeling the Hitchhiker from Texas Chainsaw Massacre, twitches and rants as the junkie prisoner Beck, and Aisha Hinds has a potentially intriguing role as Anna, a sullen young woman who insists she was wrongly arrested (we never find out if she was or not). Laurence Fishburne, doing a King of New York-meets-Morpheus turn, is so hipster-stoic-cool he's practically immobile; can this be the same actor who was so memorably unhinged in What's Love Got to do With It as the manic-sadistic Ike Turner? The movie seems more interested in Jake's Demerol addiction, or the shrink's OCD (boy, obsessive-compulsives are really hot these days -- see The Aviator, Monk, and Elektra).

I don't want to spoil the original Assault's most famous moment for those of you who haven't seen it, but suffice it to say that it involved a little girl who wanted vanilla twist. It was Carpenter's signal to the audience that all bets were off, that there was no shock he would spare if realism called for it. There's no vanilla-twist girl in Assault '05, which probably says more about the times than about director Jean-François Richet's willingness to pull out the stops.

Richet, making his English-language debut here, unveiled a film in 1997 called 'Ma 6-T va crack-er,' which one Internet Movie Database reviewer described as "a film showing and encouraging violence and revolt." That sounds like a film close to Carpenter's cynical heart, but all Assault encourages is the occasional buzz of adrenaline as most of its tiny cast is decimated. It's neither graceful nor disgraceful; it just functions and then is over.

link directly to this review at http://www.efilmcritic.com/review.php?movie=11452&reviewer=416
originally posted: 01/22/07 08:38:58
[printer] printer-friendly format  

User Comments

12/29/13 Monday Morning Lots of totally needless violence. Loved it! 4 stars
11/16/11 Golden J. Williams Jr. Good action, original was way better! 3 stars
9/23/10 PAUL SHORTT NEEDLESS REMAKE 2 stars
1/06/10 art THIS REMAKE BURIES THAT TERRIBLE 1976 VERISON! 4 stars
7/08/09 *Holy_J@lapeno* This movie makes you want more and more and more. Awesome plot and awesome action scenes 4 stars
8/29/08 Shaun Wallner Interesting storyline. 4 stars
4/25/08 art THIS REMAKE IS FIVE TIMES BETTER THE 1976 ORIGINAL MUCH MORE REALISTI B 4 stars
11/29/07 mb That was OK> 4 stars
10/21/07 fools♫gold very muchly watchable 3 stars
1/27/07 William Goss Surprisingly solid actioner and decent remake, even when logic slips up. 4 stars
11/05/06 Phil M. Aficionado Good cast but very formulaic; if violence is your thing.... 3 stars
10/01/06 Charles Tatum By the numbers action flick, I've seen worse 4 stars
3/09/06 Piz Lot's of action and decent twists. Unspecatular but watchable. 3 stars
2/03/06 Stefan Halka As far as remakes go, it was decent. Nothing special. 3 stars
1/18/06 MrsVoorheesBabyBoy Even worse than the original 2 stars
7/21/05 TheViper Only if there is nothing to do should you watch this borefest. 1 stars
7/19/05 Indrid Cold Well done but completely unremarkable in every way. 3 stars
7/07/05 J This remake assault is succesfull. 5 stars
6/18/05 aldo Enjoyable film...not much story ..but good action 4 stars
6/12/05 Brian Mitchell A combination of the idiot plot with gratuitous violence and needless profanity. 1 stars
6/08/05 John everything a remake should not be - painting by the numbers - awful 1 stars
6/04/05 ELI Christ, it wasn't THAT BAD. enjoyable? Yup! Genius? Fuck no! 4 stars
6/01/05 Monday Morning The psychiatrist needed bigger tits. Not bad entertainment, though. 4 stars
5/15/05 y2mckay Fishburne looks bored, Leguizamo annoys, Drea and Maria look hot, director LOVES head shots 3 stars
5/04/05 What a waste Hideous. A 5 star film "remade" into a turd. 1 stars
4/05/05 Eugene Mortensen go see the original not this one 2 stars
3/26/05 Denise ok 3 stars
3/22/05 The Sorrow More like "Assualt on a cult-classic"... Yet again Hollywood has fucked up!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 2 stars
1/30/05 bongeezer Not bad enough to be campy.. It's just bad 1 stars
1/30/05 Casey Tells okay 3 stars
1/30/05 Fred Pellerito Rent the original instead 2 stars
1/28/05 MorallySound I hate remakes, but this one has some balls. A completely different take on an old story. 5 stars
1/27/05 nick2k i havent seen the original, but i thought this was pretty decent. hardcore violence. =) 3 stars
1/27/05 KingNeutron gritty and somewhat realistic. 3 stars
1/26/05 Steve Michaud No match for the original, of course, but still entertaining in its own right 4 stars
1/24/05 ajay boring. the dialog was written for a 2-year-old. I was close to walking out. 2 stars
1/24/05 impartial judgement blows 1 stars
1/20/05 BlindPenguinChef Another unnessecary remake of a classic movie..you're better off gouging your eyes out 2 stars
IF YOU'VE SEEN THIS FILM, RATE IT!
Note: Duplicate, 'planted,' or other obviously improper comments
will be deleted at our discretion. So don't bother posting 'em. Thanks!
Your Name:
Your Comments:
Your Location: (state/province/country)
Your Rating:


Discuss this movie in our forum

USA
  19-Jan-2005 (R)
  DVD: 10-May-2005

UK
  N/A

Australia
  31-Mar-2005




Home Reviews  Articles  Release Dates Coming Soon  DVD  Top 20s Criticwatch  Search
Public Forums  Festival Coverage  Contests About 
eFilmCritic.com: Australia's Largest Movie Review Database.
Privacy Policy | HBS Inc. | |   

All data and site design copyright 1997-2014, HBS Entertainment, Inc.
Search for
reviews features movie title writer/director/cast