More in-depth film festival coverage than any other website!
Home Reviews  Articles  Release Dates Coming Soon  DVD  Top 20s Criticwatch  Search
Public Forums  Festival Coverage  Contests About 
Advertisement

Overall Rating
3.13

Awesome: 18.06%
Worth A Look: 18.06%
Average: 23.61%
Pretty Bad38.89%
Total Crap: 1.39%

7 reviews, 30 user ratings


Latest Reviews

One Child Nation (aka Born in China) by Jay Seaver

Kingdom (2019) by Jay Seaver

Chained for Life by Rob Gonsalves

Ready or Not by Peter Sobczynski

Nightingale, The by Jay Seaver

Line Walker 2: Invisible Spy by Jay Seaver

Death of Dick Long, The by Jay Seaver

Blinded By the Light by Lybarger

Blinded By the Light by Peter Sobczynski

Good Boys by Peter Sobczynski

subscribe to this feed


Memoirs of a Geisha
[AllPosters.com] Buy posters from this movie
by Doug Bentin

"Now we know why Spielberg bailed."
2 stars

Girls, are you tired of living with your boring old parents? Does a life of servitude or quasi-prostitution sound appealing? Long to be kept by a rich man who will probably dump you as soon as you begin to show your age? Do you yearn to learn how to pour tea and juggle fans?

If the answers to these questions is YES! you need to buy a ticket right now to Rob Marshall’s new film “Memoirs of a Geisha.”

Actually, you won’t learn much about becoming a geisha, but you will get to see lots of moving picture images of snow and cherry blossoms. You’ll watch three outstanding Chinese actresses pretend to be Japanese--a multi-cultural treat as sensitive as watching Rock Hudson play an American Indian in “Winchester ‘73.” But not quite as funny.

Yes, it’s the colorful movie of the Holiday Season, just like the glamour girl you long to be--gorgeous, but without a brain in its pretty little head.

So much for the commercial.

“A story like mine has never been told.”

In the movies? Oh, sure it has, going back at least as far as the silent version of “Stella Dallas” in 1925.

Toss out the exotica for a minute. Director Rob Marshall certainly doesn’t pay much attention to it. You won’t learn anything from “Memoirs of Geisha” about Japan during the Depression or World War II, nor will you gain a better understanding of geisha than you will from a documentay on The History Channel.

With the glamour removed, what’s left? Pretty much what we got from Jane Wyman and Lana Turner in those gloriously campy melodramas from Douglas Sirk 50 years ago, but without the saving grace of the underlying social commentary.

Ziyi Zhang stars as Sayuri, sold along with her older sister as children. The sister, less attractive, goes to the “pleasure domain” part of town. Much is made of this until she runs away and we never hear of or about her again.

Sayuri goes into training to become a geisha, but she falls victim to the jealousy of geisha Hotsumomo (Gong Li, who, if she wore a kimono made of puppy fur, would make a great Cruella DeVil) and is demoted to the rank of house servant.

But soon the nine-year old’s talents, and blue eyes, are spotted by Mameha (Michelle Yeoh) and the girl goes into geisha training after all.

So she grows into her role as Kyoto’s greatest geisha—there’s even a scene from the Hollywood backstage story tradition in which Sayuri has to dance and wow an audience of big shots. You get it: “You’re going out there a youngster, but you’ve got to come back a geisha.” All along, she dreams of true love with The Chairman (Ken Watanabe), a man at least 20 years her senior who once bought her a sno cone. From such moments are undying passion made, at least in movies like this.

A lot of the heavy-breathing occurs because of “mizu,” the practice of selling the geisha-cadet’s virginity to the highest bidder. Who will buy exploration rights to Sayuri? This creates a lot of concern, but little by way of consequence. We need to know more about this custom, especially since much is made of geishas “selling one’s talents instead of one’s body.”

Weaving herself in and out of the story is Pumpkin (Youki Kudoh), Sayuri’s best friend at the okiya--sort of a geisha boarding school. Pumpkin is the only personage in the film with a real character arc and was the only one in whom I sensed the least tragedy. The cruel Hotsumomo becomes the victim of her own envy, but she, too, wanders away and while we suspect we know her fate, it isn’t displayed to us as Pumpkin’s in. Much has been written about the possibility of acting nominations coming from this picture, but one for Kudoh is the only one I could support.

Yes, much of the film is gorgeous, but director Rob Marshall doesn’t seem to have a feel for anything but surfaces. “Kill Bill” had a better grip on Japanese culture and traditions.

At best, “Memoirs of a Geisha” is disappointing; at worst, it’s lugubriously melodramatic. Mostly, it’s just a bore.

link directly to this review at http://www.efilmcritic.com/review.php?movie=13653&reviewer=405
originally posted: 01/06/06 03:13:34
[printer] printer-friendly format  

User Comments

11/25/13 Vanessa C. Beautiful movie and the story was great. 5 stars
8/15/13 Anon It was a great and well-moving story. 4 stars
6/02/11 Bethany Pairitz Very beautifully shot movie. I was pretty moved! 4 stars
12/16/09 A Girl pretty to look at but not much else 3 stars
10/23/09 Kae I loved this movie. At the end it is a tear gerker. 5 stars
1/17/09 Shaun Wallner Fell asleep to this one. 2 stars
1/10/09 Anonymous. i wish the film was as great as its cinematography. 3 stars
4/11/08 EMILIA One of my most fave movies ever! Love! Movie critic is mean and bored with life. 5 stars
3/07/08 mb beautiful movie. loved it. 4 stars
6/14/07 Angelica I love this movie! 5 stars
12/26/06 johnnyfog Can't...look...away...movie...too...pretty!! Loved Gong Li as crazy evil psycho bitch 4 stars
10/06/06 Kara Not what I thought it was about 3 stars
6/18/06 Anastasia Jonson This movie showed me alot about Japan that I didn't know. Entertaining and educational. 5 stars
6/08/06 Lisa Extremely boring - didn't even bother to finish it. One out of five for the look of it. 1 stars
5/03/06 Ashley Hinz Who cares if most of the actors were Chinese? Flawed, but I loved it. 5 stars
4/06/06 Troy M. Grzych Best explanation about sex: Eel in the cave!! Excellent movie! 5 stars
3/24/06 jesika loved it loved it loved it- CAPTIVATING but u must read the book 1ST 5 stars
3/23/06 Meredith Harshaw Japan's so unlike Iran, where geishas were never out of the closet! 3 stars
3/08/06 Piz Chick flick where if you enjoyed the book, the movie does justice. 4 stars
2/02/06 Kankasaur 2010...6 Oscar nods to Rob Marshall's A Million Little Pieces, incl. James Frey's adaption. 5 stars
1/22/06 Musicianwriter Complaining about Chinese actors? Well, Broke Back used straight ones! Geisha is amazing! 5 stars
1/19/06 malcolm see it just for the talented and gorgeous Zhang Ziyi. very similar to "Kama Sutra: ..." 4 stars
1/11/06 Mansi Dido Zhang Ziyi excels (again) ! 4 stars
1/08/06 Sachiko The tradition of the Geisha IS still alive! The movie is extremely accurate. 5 stars
1/03/06 jcjs lovely, tender, colors, music, faces, water, ponds, story, romance, deception, love, life 5 stars
12/27/05 Chun Awkward orientalizing of a dead tradition 2 stars
12/26/05 bentable zZzZzZz 2 stars
12/26/05 Jonathon Holmes If I wanted to watch a soap opra, I would've stayed home and watched Laguna Beach on MTV! 3 stars
12/26/05 Agent DX Surprisingly good, despite bad reviews. 5 stars
12/10/05 Sergio Trite strory and painfully dull. Living death! 2 stars
IF YOU'VE SEEN THIS FILM, RATE IT!
Note: Duplicate, 'planted,' or other obviously improper comments
will be deleted at our discretion. So don't bother posting 'em. Thanks!
Your Name:
Your Comments:
Your Location: (state/province/country)
Your Rating:


Discuss this movie in our forum

USA
  09-Dec-2005 (PG-13)
  DVD: 28-Mar-2006

UK
  13-Jan-2006

Australia
  19-Jan-2006


Directed by
  Rob Marshall

Written by
  Robin Swicord
  Doug Wright

Cast
  Zhang Ziyi
  Ken Watanabe
  Michelle Yeoh
  Gong Li
  Kaori Momoi
  Tsai Chin



Home Reviews  Articles  Release Dates Coming Soon  DVD  Top 20s Criticwatch  Search
Public Forums  Festival Coverage  Contests About 
eFilmCritic.com: Australia's Largest Movie Review Database.
Privacy Policy | HBS Inc. | |   

All data and site design copyright 1997-2017, HBS Entertainment, Inc.
Search for
reviews features movie title writer/director/cast