More in-depth film festival coverage than any other website!
Home Reviews  Articles  Release Dates Coming Soon  DVD  Top 20s Criticwatch  Search
Public Forums  Festival Coverage  Contests About 

Overall Rating

Worth A Look: 17.39%
Average: 26.09%
Pretty Bad: 4.35%
Total Crap: 4.35%

5 reviews, 16 user ratings

Latest Reviews

Amiko by Jay Seaver

Man Who Killed Hitler and Then The Bigfoot, The by Jay Seaver

Laplace's Witch by Jay Seaver

Eighth Grade by Peter Sobczynski

Unfriended: Dark Web by Peter Sobczynski

Mamma Mia: Here We Go Again! by Peter Sobczynski

Boiled Angels: The Trial of Mike Diana by Jay Seaver

Buy Bust by Jay Seaver

Isle of Dogs by Rob Gonsalves

Room Laundering by Jay Seaver

subscribe to this feed

[] Buy posters from this movie
by Mel Valentin

"A love letter to cinema short on postage."
3 stars

The words “Martin Scorsese” and “family film” aren’t words critics or moviegoers would expect to see in the same sentence, but they accurately, if incompletely, describe Scorsese’s latest film, "Hugo," an adaptation of Brian Selznick’s 2008 Caldecott Medal-winning "The Invention of Hugo Cabret,' a historical children’s novel Selznick wrote and illustrated. At first glance, the period setting and the subject matter seem far outside Scorsese’s comfort zone (i.e., urban crime dramas), but Scorsese’s desire to adapt "The Invention of Hugo Cabret" gave him the opportunity to push the limits of his technical skills (i.e., working with 3D cameras, a first) and proselytize about a subject near and dear to his heart and, quite possibly, unspoken fears and anxieties about his place in film history as a master filmmaker (changing tastes three or four decades hence may change that evaluation).

Set in early 1930s Paris, Hugo centers on Hugo Cabret (Asa Butterfield, The Boy in the Striped Pajamas, a twelve-year old orphan who lives (and works) inside a train station (presumably the Montparnasse). Unbeknownst to the hostile, antagonistic station inspector (Sacha Baron Cohen), a wounded WWWI veteran, Hugo keeps the station's clocks running smoothly. As the son of a deceased clockmaker (Jude Law, seen briefly in flashbacks), Hugo shares his father's temperament (i.e., a desire to fix things, to keep things running) and his father's skills. Abandoned by his only living relative, an irresponsible, alcoholic uncle, Claude (Ray Winstone), Hugo makes do, snatching only as much food and milk necessary to survive. He's also on the lookout for gears, springs, and other mechanical gewgaws that could, in the right combination, help him repair, to rebuild, and ultimately resurrect a turn-of-the-20th-century automaton his late father found in a local museum.

All of that, of course, is backstory we learn via expository dialogue or flashback. When Papa Georges (Ben Kingsley), a stern, taciturn toy booth operator, catches Hugo attempting to lift a mechanical mouse from his shop, he threatens to turn Hugo over to the inspector. After forcing Hugo to empty his pockets and finding a notebook filled with drawings and equations (it once belonged to Hugo's father), Georges decides to keep the notebook. Unwilling to accept Georges unilateral decision to keep the notebook (Georges later claims he destroyed it), Hugo befriends Georges' precocious god-daughter, Isabelle (Chloë Grace Moretz), first to help him recover the notebook and later to help Hugo discover the automaton's secret, a secret Hugo imagines will bring him closer to his late father (he's actually expecting a message of some kind).

While Hugo initially follows a Dickensian template for Hugo's adventures and misadventures in and around the train station and the station's clocks, it's really an opportunity for Scorsese to both exercise and expand his technical skills as a filmmaker, beginning with an energetic tracking shot that literally descends from the night sky into and through the train station before settling on Hugo's eyes, peering out, unseen, from one of the station's clocks, followed by a lengthy tracking shot inside the clock tower and many more similarly impressive, immersive scenes aided by 3D cameras (no 3D post-conversion thankfully), Scorsese has another, grander (to him) project in mind for Hugo and it doesn't involve Hugo's personal and/or emotional journey and the Dickensian fate that awaits, or should await, all Dickensian heroes (i.e., a loving family).

Unfortunately, Hugo's personal journey takes a back seat to Scorsese's film preservation/film history obsession for the last thirty minutes of Hugo's running time. Once the active hero in his own story, Hugo becomes a supporting character in someone else's. Once a film historian, René Tabard (Michael Stuhlbarg), makes an appearance, Hugo becomes an extremely expensive love letter to early cinema in Europe and a polemic in favor of film preservation. Over the course of that half hour, Scorsese gives us a glimpse into turn-of-the-20th-century cinema, specifically the master illusionists and dream weavers (actually one in particular) who transformed the cinema from the mere recording of live events into elaborately choreographed, imaginative fantasies, of dreams made reel (if not real). At best, it’s superficially engaging, especially when the narrator reveals the sad, sorry fate of most of his films: destroyed for their base chemicals. Even sadder is the fate of the narrator: ignored and forgotten, forced to live in near-poverty, perpetually unappreciated.

As stirring as Scorsese's lesson in film history and film preservation may be (and your mileage may vary, depending on the level and depth of your cinephilia), they fatally undermine "Hugo's" narrative structure, a structure that depends, or should depend, on character, conflict, and choice, but instead leaves poor Hugo to sit idly by for half an hour before he's roused from immobility for one last, contrived set piece, a set piece that sends Hugo back into the clock tower to engage in one last affectionate homage (this time to Harold Lloyd’s "Safety Last!") for Scorsese, and a pat, predictable feel-good ending that feels forced and unearned (because it is, sadly).

link directly to this review at
originally posted: 11/23/11 19:27:32
[printer] printer-friendly format  

User Comments

1/23/17 Suzanne Beautiful and magical - with I could have seen it in 3D 4 stars
5/08/16 Andra Birzu An impressive and touching plot 5 stars
9/05/12 mr.mike Good but not exactly earth shattering. 4 stars
4/17/12 Dr.Lao What pretentious crap! 1 stars
3/03/12 Monday Morning Impressive at first, but went WAY too long. It ruined the movie. 2 stars
2/12/12 matthew Thompson Dalldorf An homage to film, novels and creativity in general 5 stars
1/28/12 M Why was this filmed in 3D? Trailer/Poster potray this film as something its not. 1 stars
1/26/12 Devin Sabas a must in 3d where this movie really shines 4 stars
1/13/12 Isaac A simple children’s story that's an impressive fantasy and an ode to the grandeur of cinema 5 stars
1/01/12 zenny Amazing film, beautiully made. 5 stars
12/17/11 Ming A beautiful made film. A very touching story 4 stars
12/13/11 Justin Closest actual movie version to Seinfeld's "Death Blow" 4 stars
12/09/11 al rudolf I couldn't decide if I liked it or not but Chloe was inchanting. 4 stars
11/27/11 Shaun A Went into this with no expectations and was pleasantly surprised by the escapism involved 4 stars
11/25/11 Flipsider A plodding bore. The soundtrack is terrible. 2 stars
Note: Duplicate, 'planted,' or other obviously improper comments
will be deleted at our discretion. So don't bother posting 'em. Thanks!
Your Name:
Your Comments:
Your Location: (state/province/country)
Your Rating:

Discuss this movie in our forum

  23-Nov-2011 (PG)
  DVD: 28-Feb-2012


  DVD: 28-Feb-2012

Directed by
  Martin Scorsese

Written by
  John Logan

  Chloe Moretz
  Ben Kingsley
  Sacha Baron Cohen
  Asa Butterfield

Home Reviews  Articles  Release Dates Coming Soon  DVD  Top 20s Criticwatch  Search
Public Forums  Festival Coverage  Contests About Australia's Largest Movie Review Database.
Privacy Policy | HBS Inc. | |   

All data and site design copyright 1997-2017, HBS Entertainment, Inc.
Search for
reviews features movie title writer/director/cast