More in-depth film festival coverage than any other website!
Home Reviews  Articles  Release Dates Coming Soon  DVD  Top 20s Criticwatch  Search
Public Forums  Festival Coverage  Contests About 
Advertisement

Overall Rating
3.54

Awesome: 7.32%
Worth A Look60.98%
Average: 17.07%
Pretty Bad: 7.32%
Total Crap: 7.32%

4 reviews, 17 user ratings


Latest Reviews

Fortress, The (2017) by Jay Seaver

MFA by Jay Seaver

You Only Live Once by Jay Seaver

November (2017) by Jay Seaver

Friendly Beast by Jay Seaver

Foreigner, The (2017) by Jay Seaver

Tom of Finland by Rob Gonsalves

Happy Death Day by Jay Seaver

78/52: Hitchcock's Shower Scene by Jay Seaver

Death Note: Light Up the New World by Jay Seaver

subscribe to this feed


Avengers: Age of Ultron
[AllPosters.com] Buy posters from this movie
by Brett Gallman

"A trade paperback committed to celluloid."
4 stars

With “Age of Ultron,” Joss Whedon further solidifies his place as the ideal candidate to oversee the daunting task of shepherding the Marvel Universe to the screen because he operates with a keen awareness of escalation: sensing that the world-breaking stakes of “The Avengers” can’t truly be heightened, he instead looks inwards towards his characters. “Age of Ultron” is simultaneously bigger and more intimate than its predecessor, and it works because Whedon realizes these characters have endured for decades with good reason. He’s a director who values the small panels as much as he does the huge splash pages.

Given the rambunctious, action-packed opening sequence, it’s easy to assume otherwise: we open with the Avengers cleaning up the scraps from various previous films in an effort to recover Loki’s scepter from Baron Wolfgang von Strucker (Thomas Kretschmann), one of Hydra’s last remaining heads. Holed up in a Sokovian castle, he dispatches an army of henchmen, including two super-powered meta-humans (Aaron Taylor-Johnson and Elizabeth Olsen) to fend off Earth’s mightiest heroes during a rousing but familiar prologue crafted with dodgy CGI and a jittery camera that glides through beats much like panels on a page.

After nearly a decade, such displays begin to feel rote, perhaps even a bit mechanical—and then Whedon finds a way to weave these great little character moments throughout. It’s probably impossible to recapture the thrill of seeing these characters team up for the first time, but it’s still kind of goddamn amazing that we have a movie where Thor (Chris Hemsworth) slams Mjolnir into Captain America’s (Chris Evans) shield to wipe out a bunch of Hydra goons.

It turns out that this entire sequence is a fine prelude for “Age of Ultron,” a film built on enormous action sequences but whose foundation is grounded by small character moments strewn throughout. We’re at a point where Marvel’s house style has smothered these films’ action set-pieces with a sense of pre-fabricated, mostly computer generated sameness, so it’s up to each director to carve a niche or find their voice. The latter has never been a problem for Whedon, whose signature gift for gab elevated “The Avengers” and does most of the heavy lifting here. Nearly every great moment in “Age of Ultron” owes to his willingness to engage these characters on an intimate level, be it through witty quips or ponderous dialogue.

Both are in steady supply in the immediate aftermath of the prologue, where Tony Stark (Robert Downey, Jr.) is set to host a party at Avengers Tower but squeezes in some time to convince fellow science-bro Bruce Banner (Mark Ruffalo) to experiment on Loki’s scepter to create Ultron, an artificial intelligence to monitor the entire world and repel enemy threats before they can ever arrive. Haunted by visions of a future where his failures have resulted in his friends’ deaths, he desperately seeks to eliminate the possibility without consulting the rest of the team first. Seeds of discord are planted here as Whedon begins to explore what it means to be a hero—but not before he takes a break and actually allows his heroes to party.

If there’s one sequence that aptly summarizes “Age of Ultron” (and possibly Whedon’s entire career), it’s this one: with the loose ends of one phase tied up and new ones beginning to untangle, he takes time to luxuriate in nearly every single notable character from the Marvel Cinematic Universe so far. It’s here that you realize that “Age of Ultron” distinguishes itself from its predecessor by going big in a different sort of way: if “The Avengers” was a culmination, then this is a truly proper cross-over event, with minor characters and issues from previous films (like Anthony Mackie’s Sam Wilson’s pursuit of The Winter Soldier) dropping in to give a peak at the larger universe. All that’s missing are editor’s notes referring you to the previous film.

Beyond that, this party scene represents some fantastic character work that allows everyone’s personalities a moment to shine, from James Rhodes’s (Don Cheadle) amusing insecurity about being overshadowed by the likes of Thor to Black Widow (Scarlett and Johansson) and Banner’s reluctance about exploring their obvious romantic chemistry. It’s pure Whedon: witty, yet affecting, and perhaps the closest we’ll come to Howard Hawks dealing with superheroes (you have to wonder if Friday, Stark’s replacement A.I., isn’t a nod in his direction). Even if nothing ostensibly “happens,” here, it’s immediately one of the great sequences in the MCU, particularly when everyone takes a shot at lifting Mjolnir, much to the chagrin of Thor (well, until Cap budges it, then Hemsworth--arguably the film's funniest secret weapon--shows some of his own insecurity with a hilarious show of false bravado). When you feel as if you could definitely watch a film where superheroes just hang out, the rest flows naturally.

Once Ultron awakens and instigates the plot by twisting his mission into a mandate to destroy humanity, Whedon still refuses to lose sight of these characters. Even when they’re globe-hopping to Wakanda and engaging their latest foe during another large-scale action sequence, it’s driven by their greatest fears thanks to Wanda Maximoff’s (Olsen) mental manipulation. Even though the stakes rise to the same earth-shattering levels as previous films, it feels more urgent here because Whedon directs the turmoil inward, much in the same way “Empire Strikes Back” does.

Our heroes find themselves scattered, broken, and even at each other’s throats at various points, and this is the sort of conflict that drives the film. As cool as it might be to see Stark suit up in the Hulkbuster and take down a rampaging Hulk, it’s also a bummer because watching it is a reminder that the Avengers are sometimes their own worst enemy. Even Loki would be impressed by how Ultron manipulates this bunch into practically levelling a Wakandan city (though it should be noted that Whedon goes out of his way to minimize civilian casualties).

In most movies, this calamitous stuff would be the highlights: how many action movies treat its exposition and dialogue as bridges from one set-piece to the next? Here, it’s just the opposite: save for those moments that take advantage of Whedon’s trademark character work, the action feels almost perfunctory. I often couldn’t find myself waiting to see these characters hang out again. Whedon obliges by allowing each character to thrive, especially those who have been short-changed or relegated as sidekicks in previous films. With five solo films between them, Captain America and Iron Man are known commodities serving as pillars here while Whedon explores other, underserved characters.

“Age of Ultron” particularly feels like an apology to Jeremy Renner’s Hawkeye; the ultimate 6th wheel in “The Avengers,” he emerges here as the team’s heart. Without shying away from the fact that he’s just a guy with a bunch of arrows standing among gods and superheroes, the film grounds itself through his humanity. His personal stakes—a wife and children he’s kept off the grid—feel more palatable than the threat of complete annihilation. So, too, does the tension that emerges as the team becomes further fractured by Stark’s ambitions and the super-powered twins’ waffling allegiances. Given the nature of these things, the ending is never quite in doubt: we know that Ultron will be defeated and that the Earth will be preserved. Less predictable is what shape—moral and physical—The Avengers will be left in, and “Age of Ultron” features plenty of tremors hinting at further upheaval.

Before its credits even roll, it’s already fundamentally altered the MCU by taking it into strange territory. If “Age of Ultron” can’t go bigger, it certainly can go weirder, and, considering the last Marvel movie featured a talking tree and a raccoon, that’s really saying something. Ultron himself is an oddball, less megalomaniac and more petulant teenager (at one point, he even throws a tantrum when he has his internet taken away). James Spader voices him with an insecure, sarcastic smarm that directly reflects his creator, and many of his monologues feel like the ramblings of a computer program gone awry, constantly grappling with logic and his surrogate daddy issues.

While Ultron is the latest mirror of our cultural technophobia, he particularly represents a growing fear that heroic intentions—no matter how good they may be—can spawn monsters. Even though Whedon toys with the specifics of his creation, he’s a classic Marvel character—one that calls attention to our hero’s foibles while engaging them on a philosophical level—adapted rather perfectly.

The same can be said for Vision (Paul Bettany, finally given a body after voicing Jarvis for the past 7 years), Ultron’s synthetic analogue. By far one of the strangest characters in the Marvel stable, he’s translated to the screen with his otherworldly weirdness intact. Bettany plays him less like an android and more like a distant alien sage, and Whedon lets him completely loose in the sandbox. I’m not sure I could have ever expected a movie where Vision casually swoops into the proceedings, laser beams and all. With this being Whedon’s last stint in the “Avengers” director’s chair, it feels as though he’s playing with house money and deploying so much oddness to overcome the sense of familiarity.

None of the big moments in “Age of Ultron” reach the height of those in “The Avengers,” if only because the novelty has worn off. Rather than chase that dragon, Whedon has instead crafted a weirder, more elusive dragon: “Age of Ultron” is not as immediately satisfying as its predecessor, but it does open the door a richer, more daring universe that is soon to be populated by a Sorcerer Supreme and a Wakandan king with magical powers.

Speaking of “Ultron” like it’s a cog in what has become a well-oiled machine feels like a disservice that effectively reduces it to advertising for what’s the come, but Marvel’s model has to be reckoned with or at least confronted. At this point, “Age of Ultron” can’t possibly stand alone—how could it when it’s effectively the tenth film in a franchise? Its eyes naturally dart backwards and forwards as it addresses its present concerns, so some natural unwieldiness arises during its brief digressions to lay the foundation for the next cosmos-shattering event a few years from now. Whedon admirably doesn’t allow this to overwhelm the proceedings, but viewers remain just cognizant enough that “Age of Ultron”—sprawling and massive though it may be—is but a piece in a puzzle that won’t be complete until 2019.

I don’t know if that’s necessarily a bad thing. Certainly, “Iron Man 2” revealed the worst possible scenario when this approach collapses under its own weight, but comic books have thrived on it for decades now. Few overarching storylines are ever self-contained, as creators reserve at least one panel to hint at the horizon. Massive, universe-shaking events often feed right into each other, making the medium something of a perpetual motion machine (that DC’s most notable version of this is called “Infinite Crisis” is apt). Adapting this method for the screen is arguably the most comic-booky thing imaginable, and, though it isn’t the first of its type (Universal’s stable of monsters crossed over with each other a good 70 years ago), none have been as intricately plotted as this one.

If “Age of Ultron” doesn’t feel like a complete story, it still only seems fair to meet it halfway and engage it on these terms: rather than recoil from this massive serial approach, it’s more rewarding to embrace it. One of the most dramatic and intriguing threads here—the growing gulf between Tony Stark and Steve Rogers—won’t be fully paid off until next year. When they part on good terms here, it’s shaded with a hint of bittersweet irony because we know what looms. Does this mean a good chunk of “Age of Ultron” functions as a teaser trailer for “Captain America: Civil War?” Perhaps, but both this and the obligatory mid-credits Easter egg are completely in the spirit of the final pages in a comic book hyping the next issue's adventure.

“Age of Ultron” proves the model is sustainable, so long as Marvel head honcho Kevin Feige continues to allow his directors to work within his sandbox. In Whedon especially, he found a director who nimbly worked within what has grown into an old Hollywood producer system, and hoping the Russo Brothers can make for suitable replacements is the most pressing concern moving forward—it’s hard to consider “Age of Ultron” a victory lap when the race isn’t over.

I wonder if that isn’t part of the appeal, though: clearly, these films have resonated and left a cultural footprint in a way few comic enthusiasts could have ever imagined fifteen years ago. Maybe it’s their recurrence as cinematic comfort food that resounds, and perhaps that means these films must be boilerplate productions on some level as they roll off of an assembly line.

This doesn’t mean it can’t be a well-crafted boilerplate, though, especially when their characters are as well-drawn as they are here. “Age of Ultron” doesn’t soar because it’s perfected a formula—it does so because its director realizes its most important ingredients are the true draw. The specifics of its splash pages might fade, but I’ll never forget that Joss Whedon basically gifted us something that can be considered a Hawkeye movie.

Speaking of escalation, I'm not quite sure anyone will top that--but I do know that I look forward to the attempt. That's part of the fun, even if it means we have to consider "Age of Ultron" as a piece of marketing and a movie all at once. It excels at both since "Civil War" is shaping up to be one of the most intriguing Marvel Universe films yet. I can practically see the back-page advertisement for it in my mind.

link directly to this review at http://www.efilmcritic.com/review.php?movie=24288&reviewer=429
originally posted: 05/04/15 12:23:24
[printer] printer-friendly format  
Marvel Characters: For more in the Marvel Characters series, click here.

User Comments

2/21/17 Dave Entertaining, generic superhero rubbish. Don't expect too much 3 stars
2/13/17 morris campbell very good Ultron was awesome 4 stars
2/13/17 morris campbell very good Ultron was awesome 4 stars
10/06/15 oz1701 barely watchable. redeemed (but only just) only by spader's voicing of Ultron. 2 stars
8/25/15 Noice Another comic book waste of money, tired in every way 2 stars
7/16/15 Charles Tatum Appealing actors and nice effects, on par with first film 4 stars
6/05/15 mr.mike Better than the first one. 4 stars
5/25/15 dr. lao The poorly handled romantic subplot dragged it down a star 4 stars
5/16/15 Toni Peluso Not quite as good as the first... but loved it anyway 4 stars
5/12/15 Christian Paulson Fantastic, the only things I would change really couldn't be helped so stop hating. 5 stars
5/10/15 gilz very good. will need repeat viewing s. 4 stars
5/08/15 Taylor One of the most disappointing films ever 1 stars
5/05/15 Jack Not nearly as good as the first film. 2 stars
5/04/15 KingNeutron Has so much action that it will require several re-viewings ;-) Spader and Hulk were best 5 stars
5/04/15 RS Could hardly be better 5 stars
5/02/15 Bob Dog Bulk generic superhero product. 1 stars
5/01/15 Cooler One of the most disappointing sequels ever made 1 stars
IF YOU'VE SEEN THIS FILM, RATE IT!
Note: Duplicate, 'planted,' or other obviously improper comments
will be deleted at our discretion. So don't bother posting 'em. Thanks!
Your Name:
Your Comments:
Your Location: (state/province/country)
Your Rating:


Discuss this movie in our forum

USA
  01-May-2015 (PG-13)
  DVD: 02-Oct-2015

UK
  23-Apr-2015 (12A)

Australia
  23-Apr-2015
  DVD: 02-Oct-2015




Home Reviews  Articles  Release Dates Coming Soon  DVD  Top 20s Criticwatch  Search
Public Forums  Festival Coverage  Contests About 
eFilmCritic.com: Australia's Largest Movie Review Database.
Privacy Policy | HBS Inc. | |   

All data and site design copyright 1997-2017, HBS Entertainment, Inc.
Search for
reviews features movie title writer/director/cast