More in-depth film festival coverage than any other website!
Home Reviews  Articles  Release Dates Coming Soon  DVD  Top 20s Criticwatch  Search
Public Forums  Festival Coverage  Contests About 
Advertisement

Overall Rating
3.21

Awesome: 18.75%
Worth A Look26.25%
Average: 25%
Pretty Bad: 17.5%
Total Crap: 12.5%

5 reviews, 50 user ratings


Latest Reviews

Book of Life, The (2014) by Jay Seaver

Golden Era, The by Jay Seaver

Maze Runner, The by Daniel Kelly

Art and Craft by Jay Seaver

One Chance by Jay Seaver

St. Vincent by Peter Sobczynski

Wyrmwood by Jay Seaver

Judge, The by Peter Sobczynski

Over Your Dead Body by Jay Seaver

Breakup Buddies by Jay Seaver

subscribe to this feed


Pledge, The
[AllPosters.com] Buy posters from this movie
by Rob Gonsalves

"Nicholson and Penn are one of the great star/director teams."
5 stars

In two out of his three directorial outings, Sean Penn has had the good fortune of having Jack Nicholson, unglamorous and hungry to act, as his star.

Subtle work such as Nicholson does in The Crossing Guard and now The Pledge makes up for any ten crowd-pleasing, one-hand-tied-behind-his-back Nicholson performances (like, say, As Good As It Gets). Not content to be a brilliant actor himself, Penn is shaping up to be one of the great actor's directors -- a filmmaker who lets his performers live and breathe, giving them space to invent and to inspire each other.

Nicholson rules over The Pledge with a shaky hand, and that's the source of his power here. He immerses himself in the role of Jerry Black, a Nevada detective about to retire from the force. Twice divorced, with no children that we hear about (we see a possible son in a photograph), Jerry plans rather half-heartedly to file himself away at a lake resort, fishing for marlins and waiting to die. When a little girl's body is found in the snowbound woods, raped and murdered, Jerry can't turn his back. He visits the girl's parents (Patricia Clarkson and Michael O'Keefe), promising to find her killer. He knows he can't fade into what he sees as the purgatory of retirement just yet. His brain can't shut off the deductive process.

In structure, The Pledge is only tenuously a whodunit. We see Jerry uncovering clues, making connections that others scoff at (younger cop Aaron Eckhart and captain Sam Shepard are the main scoffers), refusing to believe that the case is closed even after a confession is manipulated out of a Native American drifter (Benicio Del Toro) who is barely even aware of his surroundings. We feel Jerry's need to honor his promise and impose sense on a senseless crime. This movie, adapted by scripters Jerzy Kromolowski and Mary Olson-Kromolowski from the book The Promise by Friedrich Dürrenmatt, is similar to the overlooked 1982 drama The Border, featuring another fine, low-key performance by Nicholson as a lawman driven to do the right thing in the face of cynicism and indifference.

The Pledge also ranks among recent depressive, wintry dramas like The Sweet Hereafter and Affliction, in which the snow seems to rise to cover old wounds, old secrets, old violence. Chris Menges' photography is immaculate yet naturalistic, never overselling the chilly climate or reducing the scenery to postcards. Sean Penn is never likely to direct a feel-good romantic comedy; his gods are Bergman and Cassavetes, with perhaps a side order of the French New Wave directors. Nicholson responds to Penn's directorial muscle by allowing himself to appear weak; wrapping himself in this despairing role, he nevertheless exudes the intellectual glee of an actor who feels safe to explore, who knows he's in good hands.

Continuing his lonely hunt for the killer, Jerry buys a gas station, the better to position himself by the road and see who rolls into town. (One wonderful touch: the former gas-station owner is Harry Dean Stanton, one of many cast members known for on-screen or off-screen hellraising; others include Mickey Rourke as the numb father of another missing girl, Vanessa Redgrave as the slain girl's grandmother, and Helen Mirren as a shrink.) He also meets a waitress (Robin Wright Penn), a decent woman abused by her ex-husband, and her little daughter (Pauline Roberts). Feelings develop between the broken-down old cop and the wounded waitress, and Jerry has a kindly, grandfatherly touch with the little girl. What we begin to wonder is whether the resulting family unit is only a means to an end; we also begin to wonder about Jerry's sanity.

Almost defiantly, The Pledge leaves us with no clear-cut resolution, yet this feels like the right -- the only -- way for such an emotionally messy film to finish. At the very beginning, we see a bloodied Jerry having what appears to be a nervous breakdown; this is reprised at the end, and we understand why. Penn catches us leaning the wrong way: conditioned by whodunits to expect a lurid revelation, we are instead confronted with an anticlimax that confounds our expectations and Jerry's. Yet this question mark (closer to an ellipsis, actually) is more emphatic than the usual strained exclamation point that closes most formula Hollywood thrillers, and is more haunting than any manufactured shock ending.

Sean Penn is batting three for three now; if he wants to forego acting to concentrate on directing, I wish he'd do the latter more often, but if movies like 'The Pledge' are the result of five years of waiting for the right material, he has my blessing to wait.

link directly to this review at http://www.efilmcritic.com/review.php?movie=4785&reviewer=416
originally posted: 12/30/06 14:37:27
[printer] printer-friendly format  

User Comments

7/29/14 awclqreo USA 2 stars
6/15/12 chris conley Boring yet really acted well, the ending compeletely sinks the movie. 1 stars
9/08/10 PAUL SHORTT COMPELLING DRAMA WITH A GOOD STAR PERFORMANCE 4 stars
4/17/10 tc bronson A deep movie. Didn't like the ending tho 5 stars
1/27/08 Mo I want two hours of my life back--horrible movie 1 stars
5/25/07 fools♫gold A TRUE cult flick, like this year's "Premonition," which FEW people fall in love with. 5 stars
9/15/06 Charles Tatum Effective but depressingly downbeat 4 stars
12/24/04 Landshark filling station for the miserable 4 stars
12/05/04 paul watson Brilliant, 1st Penn I'veseen, I am glad he doesnt pander to the masses. True Storytelling 5 stars
9/04/04 T.B. It very boring... 2 stars
8/21/04 jane dough Really dumb from the git go. After that, mostly predictable. Tediously slow pacing. 1 stars
5/10/04 R.W. Welch Ironic detective story sags some in the middle but has impressive performances. 4 stars
2/03/04 Phil M. Aficionado Contrived with loose ends and plot holes to save fine acting & good commentary on obsession 3 stars
10/11/03 JimmyC Probobly the worst JACK movie ever made. 1 stars
9/23/03 Alice very boring to me, pointless 2 stars
8/24/03 the illuminati You know what? This was a good flick! I liked that it wasn't so tight and restrictive... 4 stars
7/09/03 natasha_theobald not afraid of quiet moments, gentle pacing, or ambiguity 4 stars
6/05/03 JoeSco well done and full marks to Penn for the ending 4 stars
3/03/03 Jack Sommersby Very involving and brilliantly atmospheric, but also metaphorically dense. 3 stars
1/22/03 Pinkline Jones Excellent - disturbing - thoughtful 5 stars
7/20/02 ! I just didnt get it.. 3 stars
6/29/02 The Bomb69 not a hollywood ending so most won't like it, glad Penn went this route 4 stars
2/01/02 Terrie Smith Intense and moody; Nicholson is good. Ending will please few. 4 stars
1/29/02 Law Firm of Dewey, Cheatam & Howe A little more overacting than I can stand, still waiting for Sean's masterpiece 3 stars
1/21/02 Jonas Kyratzes A great movie, but not one everybody is going to understand. 5 stars
11/14/01 Jimbo Good thriller. Worth seeing 4 stars
10/22/01 Alex subtle and powerful 5 stars
8/19/01 stanley beautiful, slower-than-expected "thriller" 4 stars
8/18/01 Marcs Excellent! 5 stars
8/18/01 onesmartcookie This really could have been good...I was anticipating a closure and got the ending credits 4 stars
8/14/01 Lalo Linguini Way slow, with a dissapointing ending. Could have been so much better. 3 stars
8/09/01 Danny & Sharon BIG stars, BIG TALK,drawn out and badly scripted . but same all story . Film Fest Flop 2 stars
8/06/01 E-Funk So intense! Penn proves he can direct, Jack just does what he does best...be a pimp. 4 stars
6/30/01 othree a going nowhere angst movie, still love Sean Penn and Jack Nicholson. 3 stars
6/28/01 Monday Morning Way too slow. At least 30 mins. of filler should have been surgically removed. 1 stars
6/26/01 Madonna Not beaten, bitchslapped by me like the old days you pompous moron... 1 stars
6/26/01 SeanPenn I should be beaten for producing and directing this garbage. Sorry. I am an idiot. 1 stars
6/26/01 JesseL A profound combination of boring tedium and depressing cliche. Cameraman on LSD. 1 stars
6/15/01 J Ignore those pan this film. It was excellent! 5 stars
3/24/01 pat The most irritatingly stupid movie of the year....couldnt sit thru 1 stars
3/22/01 anne corsi terrific movie 5 stars
2/04/01 3 star Mickey Rourke small role ,great acting, Film so so 3 stars
2/03/01 jane fazzari Very weak, too many holes and loose ends. 2 stars
1/25/01 jon j the feel good movie of the year! 2 stars
1/25/01 Jim Shertzer Grim, difficult but persistent involving and compelling film with a fewunrealized ambitions 4 stars
1/22/01 John Park Worst....Movie....Ever! The suckiest suck that ever sucked! DO NOT SEE!!!! 1 stars
1/22/01 28 yowm It started like it was going to be a suspense thriller and then kind of dragged on and on.. 2 stars
1/22/01 Daniel Gonzales Jr suspense, high tension, good example of obsessional behavior 4 stars
1/22/01 Evan Price banal... pretentious... virtual absence of direction 2 stars
1/20/01 Angela M. Murtagh entertaining at first...not a very good ending... 3 stars
IF YOU'VE SEEN THIS FILM, RATE IT!
Note: Duplicate, 'planted,' or other obviously improper comments
will be deleted at our discretion. So don't bother posting 'em. Thanks!
Your Name:
Your Comments:
Your Location: (state/province/country)
Your Rating:


Discuss this movie in our forum

USA
  19-Jan-2001 (R)

UK
  N/A

Australia
  09-Aug-2001 (R)




Home Reviews  Articles  Release Dates Coming Soon  DVD  Top 20s Criticwatch  Search
Public Forums  Festival Coverage  Contests About 
eFilmCritic.com: Australia's Largest Movie Review Database.
Privacy Policy | HBS Inc. | |   

All data and site design copyright 1997-2014, HBS Entertainment, Inc.
Search for
reviews features movie title writer/director/cast