Overall Rating
  Awesome: 87.3%
Worth A Look: 3.17%
Average: 3.17%
Pretty Bad: 1.59%
Total Crap: 4.76%
2 reviews, 51 user ratings
|
|
| Grave of the Fireflies |
by Jay Seaver
"You know it won't end well - because war can't."
|
Movies about soldiers, generals, and national leaders don't really get at why war is so awful. In even the most militarized societies, there's still a massive civilian population of people that try to go on living their lives in much the same way, only with a million times the stress placed on them. Most confused are children, who aren't yet equipped to understand just why the world has changed so much.Isao Takahata's Grave of the Fireflies (from a novel by Akiyuki Nosaka) tells the story of a brother and sister trying to survive during the American firebombing of Japan during World War II. The boy, Seita, is about twelve; his sister, Setsuko, is about five. Their father is in the Navy; they lose their mother early on. An aunt takes them in, but soon grows to resent them, and they strike out on their own.
It's clear from the very first scene that this movie will not end well. War movies often don't, but there's no doubt here; we see Seita alone and in a pitiful state before flashing back to watch the events that led him there. Indeed, the Seita we see helping his mother and sister prepare for evacuation is almost unrecognizable compared to the gaunt, dying, rag-clad young man of the opener. There's an understated determination to this Seita, although I'd stop short of calling it bravery. He's too naive to truly understand what he's facing early on, and his later courage is a kind of foolish bravery.
It's a foolish bravery because Takahata doesn't idealize his protagonist. Certainly, Setusko is a cute little moppet, but she's five and unable to truly understand the war beyond that her parents have gone away for a while and she can't get more candy. Seita attempts to shield her, and there's a certain nobility in his attempts to allow Setsuko to keep thinking of the world as a good and amazing place despite what's going on around them. Less noble is his attempt to stay a child himself. The children's aunt is kind of nasty, but she's got a point when she points out that Seita isn't helping out much. His purchase of a rice-cooker so that he and Setsuko don't have to share their food is an act of defiance, and his decision to leave their foster home is ill-considered to say the least. As good and self-sufficient as he may be, he's not ready to shoulder the responsibility for someone else.
I have, up until this point, been somewhat careful to avoid mentioning that Grave of the Fireflies is animated. In the United States, animation is often treated more as a genre than a medium, and the idea that a movie can be both animated and a serious drama is greeted with a bit of skepticism. Why not simply do it as live action, one may ask. That Takahata is an animator should be the only explanation necessary.
This film does show him to be one of the masters of the medium. The character designs are flawless, from the rounded Setsuko to the gangly (but serious) Setia. The depictions of war's horrors balances is never graphic enough to come across as exploitative, but never understated, either. He knows when detail adds power and when it is distracting. He steadfastly resists the temptation to cram more onto the screen when stillness is more effective.Grave of the Fireflies is a quiet movie about the collision between how a child looks at the world and an environment which makes no allowances for a child's innocence. Among those who have seen it, it is often described as one of the best films about war every made, and deservedly so.
link directly to this review at http://www.efilmcritic.com/review.php?movie=7404&reviewer=371
originally posted: 03/12/05 05:04:12
![[printer]](/images/icon/printer.gif) printer-friendly format
|
 |
USA
16-Apr-1988 (PG)
UK
N/A
Australia
N/A
|
|
Articles 
subscribe to this feed![[AllPosters.com]](/images/icon/ap.gif){kind=icon}
