More in-depth film festival coverage than any other website!
Home Reviews  Articles  Release Dates Coming Soon  DVD  Top 20s Criticwatch  Search
Public Forums  Festival Coverage  Contests About 

Overall Rating

Awesome: 10.34%
Worth A Look: 13.79%
Average: 20.69%
Pretty Bad: 24.14%
Total Crap31.03%

3 reviews, 11 user ratings

Latest Reviews

Homewrecker (2019) by Jay Seaver

Gemini Man by Jay Seaver

Pain and Glory by Peter Sobczynski

Rusalka (aka The Siren), The by Jay Seaver

Riot Girls by Rob Gonsalves

Crawl by Rob Gonsalves

Wallflower by Rob Gonsalves

Parts You Lose, The by Jay Seaver

Dilili in Paris by Jay Seaver

First Love by Jay Seaver

subscribe to this feed

Miracle at St. Anna
[] Buy posters from this movie
by brianorndorf

"Spike Lee's integrity: 1986-2008"
1 stars

Disney, being Disney, has marketed “Miracle at St. Anna” as something heroic, historically challenging, and action-packed; presenting Spike Lee’s latest film as the African-American counterpart to features such as “Saving Private Ryan” and “Flags of Our Fathers.” I’ve seen many cases of outright fraudulent advertising in my day, but “St. Anna” takes the cake. Pushed as a film of astonishing cultural depth, Spike Lee has actually manufactured a picture of numbing constipation, frenzied melodrama, and racial characterization so bitterly one-dimensional, it’s almost impossible to believe the feature isn’t a flat-out cartoon. The real miracle of “St. Anna” is how anyone could stomach such crude filmmaking and blatant disregard for the finer edge of drama.

In 1944, members of the 92nd Infantry Division (the “Buffalo Soldiers”) found themselves behind enemy lines in Italy with German forces breathing down their necks. For Aubrey Stamps (Derek Luke), Bishop Cummings (Michael Ealy, spending every frame of film reminding the audience he’s wearing a gold tooth), Hector Negron (Laz Alonzo), and simpleton Sam Train (Omar Benson Miller), the situation is grim, but hope arrives when they locate an isolated village with a welcoming populace. With Nazis closing in, racism shadowing their every move, and Train finding comfort in the company of a traumatized Italian boy, the soldiers are left to fend for themselves as danger mounts and the war takes a psychological toll that radically confronts their patriotism.

“St. Anna” is not a war film. Perhaps Lee would disagree, since major time and money has been sunk into pedestrian combat zone recreations, bolstered by deafening sound effects, scads of explosions, and an exploitative, Eli Roth-like attention to bloody stubs and splattery bullet hits (even an infant bayoneting to casually remind the audience Nazis were evil). The war in this WWII picture is just a scrim; chaos being a rodeo clown to keep itchy crowds in their seat while Lee goes after his perennial brass ring: racial discord.

Scripted by James McBride (working from his own novel), “St. Anna” is viewed by Lee as the ultimate statement of justice; his chance to bring the African-American wartime experience to the big screen, literally thumbing his nose at John Wayne and all the whitewashed history his jingoistic kind represents. It’s an admirable effort, certainly a worthwhile opinion, yet “St. Anna” is a crushingly glacial and superficial fiasco from Lee, who has abandoned his sense of limitation and nuance to lustfully plant his flag as the savior of black history. As an insightful statement on the racial injustice of the segregated Buffalo Soldiers, “St. Anna” reduces the achievements of these brave men to shallow sequences of southern-fried bigotry and needlessly amplified line readings that dip a toe into self-parody, not to mention overall performances that feel like deleted scenes from Lee’s own “Bamboozled.”

Lee is craving an epic scope in a limited location. McBride’s script is replete with characters and motivations to load the dramatic plate to a breaking point, bringing in: compassionate Italian resistance figures, a subplot with the Gumpesque Train and his newfound charge, the successful sexual harassment of the village’s most attractive female (a soft-core diversion that has no place here), and the hayseed leadership of the U.S. forces, who are more than willing to lead their African-American soldiers to the slaughter to sate their unbridled prejudice (performed with Larry the Cable Guy-style flamboyance by Walton Goggins).

Also, there’s the film’s implausible framing device, establishing Negron as the composed murderer of a familiar postal customer in 1983, leading to the discovery of an important Italian artifact in his apartment that stokes the curiosity of an inexperienced newspaper reporter (Joseph Gordon-Levitt). It’s a grand setup to a movie that never bothers to match its compelling commencement, electing to get lost in meandering dialogue, vague philosophical plotting, and a rudimentary portrayal of Nazism straight out of “Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade.” The topper? Lee takes 160 minutes of screentime to arrive at a point of utter inconsequence. I swear the film feels like it takes five years to finish.

With Terence Blanchard’s wall-to-wall score clumsily pushing broad themes at all the wrong moments and Lee stuffing bizarre cameos everywhere, “St. Anna” isn’t just a mess, it’s a deliberate muddle. With Lee it’s always been all or nothing, but this picture, above all his other work, is aiming to rewrite the history books, a film with a direct purpose. Why Lee didn’t settle down and sort out his dramatic priorities before production began is a question I cannot answer, but “Miracle at St. Anna” is as disorganized, unfulfilling, and lifeless a picture as Lee is capable of making. That’s right, it’s “She Hate Me” bad.

link directly to this review at
originally posted: 09/27/08 04:16:05
[printer] printer-friendly format  
OFFICIAL SELECTION: 2008 Toronto International Film Festival For more in the 2008 Toronto International Film Festival series, click here.

User Comments

5/16/12 fartvenugen This movie is absolute crap. Ridiculous on every level. 1 stars
8/12/11 chris Great Idea, bad execution by stupid director who won't let things die. 1 stars
2/08/11 Phineas Spike, Black contributions to WWII were totally unimportant and irrelevant - LIVE WITH IT!! 1 stars
1/22/11 Jeff Wilder A good film overall? A masterpiece on par with some of Lee's best films? No. 4 stars
8/14/09 mr.mike A tough call, many plusses and minuses. Judge for yourself... 4 stars
7/20/09 Servo It's really just a mess. Also, according to Lee, every white man was a psychotic racist. 2 stars
4/27/09 Baloney A visceral pastiche that conjures haunting images of America's forgotten past. 5 stars
3/30/09 Suresh Govindasamy Absolutely astounding! a true marvel in filmaking! 5 stars
9/28/08 J. Tyler great movie, the article sounds like a film student. 5 stars
9/28/08 Lynn Rosenthal I loved this picture. 4 stars
Note: Duplicate, 'planted,' or other obviously improper comments
will be deleted at our discretion. So don't bother posting 'em. Thanks!
Your Name:
Your Comments:
Your Location: (state/province/country)
Your Rating:

Discuss this movie in our forum

  26-Sep-2008 (R)
  DVD: 10-Feb-2009


  DVD: 10-Feb-2009

Home Reviews  Articles  Release Dates Coming Soon  DVD  Top 20s Criticwatch  Search
Public Forums  Festival Coverage  Contests About Australia's Largest Movie Review Database.
Privacy Policy | HBS Inc. | |   

All data and site design copyright 1997-2017, HBS Entertainment, Inc.
Search for
reviews features movie title writer/director/cast