More in-depth film festival coverage than any other website!
Home Reviews  Articles  Release Dates Coming Soon  DVD  Top 20s Criticwatch  Search
Public Forums  Festival Coverage  Contests About 

Overall Rating

Worth A Look: 5.19%
Average: 2.83%
Pretty Bad: 8.02%
Total Crap: 2.83%

4 reviews, 188 user ratings

Schindler's List
[] Buy posters from this movie
by John Linton Roberson

"Shouldn't A Holocaust Film Be About Those Who Suffered It?"
2 stars

Schindler's List. Treated as holy. Why? Because a big filmmaker decided on a big subject. And treated it as piously and shallowly as humanly possible. You heard me. Read on.

It's the Holocaust version of MISSISSIPPI BURNING; the victims have no voice, no personality, whereas the Nazis have lots. And there were two scenes set up in such a Hollywood comic way that even a Jewish friend with me when I saw it couldn't help laughing a bit. I'm thinking of when you first see Fiennes, close up on his balcony, picking off unseen people from afar lazily; the other are the bungled executions, the one in the camp and his own. The Hollywood style is based on manipulation of emotions and Spielberg just couldn't stop, and didn't seem to think a Holocaust film had to be grim ALL the way through.

I always found it interesting that TV did a much better job dramatizing the Holocaust than film ever did. There's not a Holocaust film the equal of MAUS, even. Spielberg couldn't help using all the damn cheap Hollywood "invisible style"(HA!) tricks.

Its lack of success in my eyes I can only express as: I could easily tell it was a Spielberg film.

Compare Fiennes' character with Michael Moriarity in HOLOCAUST, an emotionally wrenching character because we see him slowly, mundanely, lose his soul; he's all the Eichmanns without which the Holocaust couldn't have run, the guys just doing their jobs. Fiennes' character is, at best, a slightly more brutal Sgt. Schultz.

And again, all that sufferin' silent poignant grateful-to-the-gentile victimry. Spielberg seems to think the story of the Holocaust is best told from the point of view of the Nazis, and well, that kind of disturbs me. Like CRY FREEDOM had to mostly be about Kevin Kline's reaction to Biko's murder, not Biko himself.

Also: in HOLOCAUST they devote a generous section to the Warsaw Uprising, which puts the lie to the well-trod myth there was no resistance, an idea that is often used by some idiots here and there to almost justify(!) the persecution, in a well-if-you-didn't-fight-what-did-you-EXPECT-kind of way. (There was, it was just crushed)

You'd never know this from Spielberg, just as you'd barely know there was a civil rights movement apart from three kids--two white--from MISSISSIPPI BURNING. Which wouldn't bother me except the way this movie has been canonized irks me mightily, as somehow the WAR & PEACE of the Holocaust. The one focused on the gentile. Yeah. Whatever. Christ, the 90s were a terrible decade for Best Pictures, weren't they?

Find HOLOCAUST and rent it, or PLAYING FOR TIME, or read MAUS or NIGHT. Anything but this piece of self-important monstrosity.

link directly to this review at
originally posted: 02/16/00 19:45:20
[printer] printer-friendly format  

User Comments

4/25/16 Katrina Weiss must watch movie 5 stars
2/10/15 martin alexander rubbish film. dont watch it because it waste your time 1 stars
3/30/12 Jonathan Essential viewing 5 stars
2/15/12 stanley welles poignant, powerful, bone-chilling, mesmerising 5 stars
8/27/10 InsanityCap This is the only film on the face of the planet that has made me weep so hard 5 stars
6/08/10 Flathead King A well paced film but the acting and script are mediocre 3 stars
6/04/10 User Name In the top three of the best films of the 90's. 5 stars
4/20/10 Meghan Gianni-Bradford As close as we will ever get to having a good view of both sides 5 stars
4/13/10 Mariah One of the best movies ever made. Anyone with a shred of sympathy will be touched 5 stars
12/10/09 Red Rubbish... pure jewish propaganda and you all bought into it. Holocaust = Hoax 1 stars
1/10/09 Anonymous. the best holocaust-related flm made IMO, though not my favorite...hard to watch... 5 stars
12/06/08 Jonathan Essential viewing. "Schindler's List" is the mark of a true master filmmaker. 5 stars
8/06/08 Max One of the best films ever made 5 stars
6/19/08 noops grt direction and grt cast... 5 stars
3/05/08 action movie fan a bore-jurassic park was the best film of 1993 1 stars
1/26/08 proper amateur film critic The final masterpiece of the 20th century 5 stars
1/06/08 dave gutierrez great movie 5 stars
12/15/07 stormsiren awesome film by an awesome director 5 stars
11/20/07 vick brown perfect 5 stars
9/25/07 petey MUST SEE 5 stars
6/25/07 fools♫gold I've underrated "Shanghai Ghetto", which undoubtedlly deserves 5 stars. 5 stars
6/15/07 ryan you're an idiot and someone should shoot you. 5 stars
5/19/07 Leandra This film stirred up emotions in me i have never known existed. It is a Masterpiece!! 5 stars
3/05/07 izzy An incredibly dark and intense film of overwhelming power and emotional impact 5 stars
2/01/07 Matt Spielberg's masterpiece is essential for anybody with half a brain. Neeson is superb. 5 stars
1/13/07 Clayton A cinematic masterpiece at every level... 5 stars
1/09/07 Drew Galletti A Masterpiece 5 stars
1/01/07 johnnyfog There is no comparison to the trite M.Burning. Very sad when Neelson cries at the end 5 stars
10/19/06 David Pollastrini brilliant, frightening 5 stars
10/17/06 Isaac Baranoff Very, very good. Highly recommended. 5 stars
8/06/06 Chris Wilbik Realistic and sad movie of the lifes of jewish people 5 stars
5/20/06 chienne Severely depressing, but an excellent film. Even Neeson was good. 5 stars
3/06/06 Nina It has been one of the best movies that I have watched and that was based on a true story.. 5 stars
11/18/05 Chris Barrett A Tearjerker! Those Who Say It's Crap Have No Heart 5 stars
9/16/05 Daveman A sick targedy, cheapened by Spielberg schmaltz and LIES. 2 stars
9/02/05 Zack wonderfly maid, Who was the bastard u voted total crap? any it was sad :( but good 5 stars
8/26/05 Michael Very Good Movie 5 stars
8/17/05 ES This one and old yeller 8*( 5 stars
8/08/05 Moctezuma The Pianist is better, but this one is still good 4 stars
6/11/05 Adam A masterpiece in filmaking, very sad but a story that had to be told 5 stars
6/08/05 me a good 'make-out' movie 4 stars
4/24/05 Quigley an amazing story, but a very dark one at that. it'd be hard to watch again for sure. really 4 stars
4/16/05 Carol Conway Fantastic movie 5 stars
4/14/05 Frenzy Superb 5 stars
3/26/05 Denise great 5 stars
3/18/05 indrid cold Its effect stays with you for days afterwords. A masterpiece in every way. 5 stars
3/18/05 B. D. Cole One of the best films of all time 5 stars
3/14/05 The Talking Elbow Spielberg "sexed up" Schindler from reality. Still a great movie though. 5 stars
3/01/05 CanDance Walker I love true stories & the younger generation needs to know about the holocaust. 5 stars
3/01/05 Jeanette T. A life experience rather than a movie. Literally unforgettable. 5 stars
2/27/05 Charlene Javier Best. Film. Ever 5 stars
2/26/05 Joy Venters EXCELLENT - EVERYONE SHOULD SEE THIS 5 stars
2/26/05 Theresa Wagner Brings the horror of the holocaust to the present 5 stars
2/26/05 James Kiang Powerful film that still is relevant. 5 stars
2/23/05 andrea313 Hard to watch in places, but certainly worth the heartache. 5 stars
2/06/05 daveyt couldn't agree less with the review... 5 stars
12/15/04 Tom Benton The best film ever made, Spielberg's finest; Neeson does one of the best acts in history. 5 stars
12/07/04 keithers.. To depressing to enjoy but extremely well done 4 stars
12/01/04 mohit best edited and directed film have ever seen 5 stars
11/25/04 gentile Even if your not a jew you will be touched. 5 stars
11/25/04 T. Maj Spielberg just now heard about the Holocaust. 2 stars
10/26/04 ELI ARG! This film is really, really depressing 5 stars
10/25/04 UMER steven's best movie direction ever 5 stars
10/23/04 ODH Boring film that is more disturbing than anything. 2 stars
10/20/04 Pinkline Jones I didn't laugh once. And this won Best Comedy 1 stars
10/07/04 Desperado Alien VS Predator hmm you're a blithering dipshit who doesnt understand what movies r about 5 stars
8/04/04 Chloe Montana critic...yes, you are a faggot... 5 stars
7/27/04 Luke "THere will be generations to generations because of what you did". 5 stars
7/16/04 Chlo-mo-bo God...breathtaking...just...beautiful... 5 stars
6/27/04 Christy A movie that still haunts me today, ten years later. I'll never be the same. 5 stars
6/18/04 T. Maj Steven Spielberg just found out about the Holocaust? 2 stars
5/07/04 katie burtsell i thought it was so touching 5 stars
4/25/04 Carla oh my god, i was touched, i was moved, i felt completely numb, like i'd left my body. 5 stars
4/25/04 MetallicA Anyone who gives this a sucks rating is a shit excuse for a human 5 stars
4/20/04 TonyMontana Everyone who gives this sucks is nothing short of a faggot. 5 stars
3/18/04 Schmidty How you could you not like something about the war, and as sad as this 5 stars
2/28/04 Kyle A horrifying movie and a good movie: NOT THE SAME DAMN THING. Flawed and exploitive. 2 stars
2/19/04 MP Bartley Astonishing, moving piece of work. And not just because it's 'revered'. It's just that good 5 stars
2/13/04 Bryand The best film for the people with high I.Q 5 stars
1/30/04 fgifhjiefe Ray Hall and Lance Everest are stupid fucks. This movie is the best. 5 stars
1/08/04 Chlo Gyllenhaal Oh my God...this should have won so many more oscars than it did! Damn the Academy! 5 stars
12/14/03 luke How-can-you-not-like-this!!!! 5 stars
12/10/03 Desperado Ray Hall, Lance Everest= Absolute Dipshits, Extraordinary 5 stars
11/29/03 DM John L. Roberson, go fuck yourself. 5 stars
11/27/03 John pretty good film that could have been better (as in THE PIANIST or LIFE IS BEAUTIFUL) 3 stars
11/18/03 *A Monotonous Creton who loves Tom Hulce* ha dto do a 9th grade essay on it; fuck anyone who hates it! damn u!!!!!!!!!!! 5 stars
10/12/03 Shaq This fucking film was like a tiny little turd-nugget dangling from my asshole. IT ROCKED! 5 stars
10/02/03 Mattocks Okay movie 4 stars
9/29/03 Kyle A MASTERPIECE. Only a handful of films can claim that title. 5 stars
9/21/03 Fenris BULLSHIT! As historically accurate as Indiana Jones ... 1 stars
9/06/03 Jess o Totally moving,Both horrific and amazing film and everyone should be made to see it. 5 stars
8/14/03 Jeannie Karlsen My first introduction to actor Ralph Fiennes. His performance is absolute perfection. 5 stars
8/02/03 DM Anybody who gives less than 4 out of 5 stars should be shot! Great movie! 5 stars
7/12/03 Indrid Cold As deep as a frisbee, but almost unbelievably powerful and moving. Stays with you forever. 5 stars
4/27/03 Megan The book was more powerful, but the film still gave this horribly true story justice 5 stars
4/27/03 Jon "Thumb the Toad" Lyrik Horrific, yet great film. 5 stars
4/16/03 JL This movies is excellent. 5 stars
3/31/03 Jessica Davis Good news: It amply deserved Best Pic win. Bad News: That puts it in company with SHITCAGO! 5 stars
3/28/03 Gray wish it was more historicaly truthful but it does convay the gravity of the Holocaust 5 stars
3/22/03 Jack Sommersby Great period detail, but the dramatic core is hollow and the characters ill-defined. 2 stars
2/11/03 Ubu the Ripper Want to know what Jews, Jehovah's Witnesses, and gays experienced? This is real. 5 stars
2/10/03 Paul Decent 3 stars
1/24/03 Jeremy Wonderful in every respect. I loved this film. 5 stars
1/08/03 Seppo Only Spielberg can make this kind of masterpiece! 5 stars
11/29/02 Jay Excellent movie! 5 stars
11/23/02 Kyle A good movie, but TV did it better in 1978's miniseries "Holocaust" 3 stars
8/26/02 Jo Not really all that truthful, but quite emotive 4 stars
6/05/02 Todd something everyone should see 5 stars
2/27/02 Shrike Brilliant film making from a 5 stars
2/17/02 Meryl K. Fiennes and Neeson were immaculate. The movie is brilliantly distressing - see it. 5 stars
1/27/02 Lin Rainey I sat spellbound through the entire film..tragic, haunting, uplifting. 5 stars
12/20/01 Heather Smyth I great film, not unjoyable to watch in any way but it protrays the holocaust brilliantly 5 stars
12/17/01 chuck all u that say this film is crap, shut up u nazis 5 stars
10/24/01 kris one of the best movies I have ever seen 5 stars
9/06/01 Gary Astounding. Spielberg's finest hour. Amazing. 5 stars
8/31/01 spaceworm Let us all now genuflect at the alter of Spielberg. 5 stars
8/25/01 John Roberson Matthew, you will find that info IN THE REVIEW. And what do YOU know? 2 stars
7/28/01 Henry Ginsberg very moving .Spielberg's best film yet . 5 stars
7/05/01 Matthew Bartley Why does John roberson have a vendetta against this film?What the fuck do you know anyway? 5 stars
6/28/01 John Roberson "Almost?" Rampage, it takes a Spielberg film to make you wish the Nazis never happened?!?) 2 stars
5/31/01 Ben Donnelly ok 3 stars
4/30/01 The Jedi Droid what can I say...what a film...emotional, & the black & white really added alot to the film 5 stars
4/23/01 Rampage it was good, almost made you wish the term Nazi never happened 4 stars
4/21/01 *~Danielle*Ophelia~* (formerly KyLe*BrOfLoVsKi) This film touched me deeply...and no, not just because I'm Jewish... 5 stars
4/16/01 Tam Heart-rending and profound, one of the finest films ever 5 stars
4/09/01 James Beetlejuice, you are a fucking moron.....nuff said 5 stars
3/18/01 Beetlejuice It was boring to me. Sorry. 3 stars
2/17/01 Michael Nicholls It emotionally drains the viewer, leaving little to spare... 5 stars
2/14/01 Lee Faultless and important 5 stars
1/15/01 Skip A masterpiece. Don't hate it because it's Spielberg. 5 stars
1/01/01 Msitrab Staggering 5 stars
12/31/00 kevin An excellent movie, one of Spielberg's best. It draws you into the plot and shows you life 5 stars
12/28/00 Viking If you don't like this movie, join the intellectual wankers at a Peter Greenaway festival 5 stars
11/26/00 Jack Wolverton I think this is the greatest film ever made. At the end I just set there in shock, awesome 5 stars
11/24/00 Cristopher Revilla you panners, pay attention or don't bother to review, you fucking morons, the film is great 5 stars
11/21/00 Randy Eischer The nude scenes were pretty good, though. 2 stars
11/18/00 The Bill Head The best movie of the 90s! Classic..Superb..Spielberg's best!On my top ten of all time... 5 stars
8/16/00 Lucritia I thik it was good of Steven to focus on schindler and what he did.He did not favour nazis 4 stars
8/04/00 Jake Ryan, That is soooooo true. What a total waste. "Oh No, I am a Jew!" 1 stars
7/26/00 fred wicked but gruesome 5 stars
7/11/00 Jami An absolutely amazing film. Ryan, you make me sick 5 stars
7/06/00 Matthew Bartley Ryan how can you say racist shit like IT'S JUST ANOTHER JEW MOVIE? 5 stars
6/27/00 Christian Zell Great film. Fiennes was incredible as Amon Goethe. 5 stars
6/12/00 perverted pixie Painful- yet exceptional. A classic. That red dress... 5 stars
6/01/00 TERRIE SMITH A emotional experience. One of the best during the 1990's. 5 stars
5/23/00 Steven Hunter This film is awesome. Naysayers wouldn't know a gret movie if it took up home in their arse 5 stars
5/05/00 matt touching 5 stars
4/26/00 Fran I wouldn't watch it again 'cause it's to bad if you see all this people. 4 stars
4/12/00 TJ St John Matthew, you're right, John Linton is an asshole!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 5 stars
4/06/00 Bruce A hard film to watch, but you will be glad you did 5 stars
3/31/00 Matthew Bartley John Linton, you're a dickhead. How can you not acknowledge it's brilliance? 5 stars
3/18/00 Ashley superb 5 stars
2/17/00 k.tomkowski Grossly overrated, because of the subject and director. 2 stars
11/29/99 Mic The Greatest Film Ever Made. I wish I had 5,000 words to write about this movie. 5 stars
11/29/99 Crystal Fleming Well done movie 5 stars
11/28/99 Stephanie Arden Fantastic a movie to be seen by everyone, to eduacate people the harm war devauors ITS GREA 5 stars
11/19/99 Lisa Solinas I was so drained after watching this, I flipflopped through a thousand emotions 5 stars
11/07/99 Anthony Ellis One of the great movie masterpieces. If not the greatest. A remarkable landmark in cinema!! 5 stars
10/30/99 Marita Absolutely extrodanary 5 stars
10/26/99 Eva Davis It was a very powerful, awsom movie 5 stars
10/11/99 Weird Andy A laff riot. Rent "Shoah" or "Hotel Terminus" instead, and actually learn something. 2 stars
10/11/99 Eran ( Basically ,whoever hates the film-hates jews.It's as simple as that. 5 stars
10/09/99 sophia962 Stunning, haunting, every corny fucking thing there is to say but they're all TRUE 5 stars
9/16/99 Casey Wright & Merryn Rogan Excellent!! 5 stars
9/04/99 godsdog Intensely disturbing, immaculately executed. Spielburg is a brilliant storyteller, bar non 5 stars
7/07/99 Ben Leostein Rating: **** (out of ****) Category: "Excellent" 5 stars
5/25/99 iyu Best movie on the planet. Period. 5 stars
4/20/99 Tim To all those people who think the Holocaust is a hoax, watch this movie. 5 stars
3/22/99 A. M. Spielbergs best work. He will never top this. In fact it may have been inadvertant. 5 stars
2/09/99 Bob, Lord of Evil How can you not acknowledge how amazing it was? 5 stars
2/02/99 Matthew Bartley What can be said? You should be made to see this film by law. Watch it, weep and watch it a 5 stars
1/24/99 Slugmuffin A timeless masterpiece. A MUST see. 5 stars
1/23/99 Goofaloo A work of art. An epic that will be long remembered. 5 stars
1/19/99 donkey_dew This is probably the greatest movie ever made. 5 stars
1/10/99 Dasha If any film can come close to perfection, it's this one. 5 stars
11/26/98 Mr.Pink I agree with the last line of K-dog's review. 5 stars
11/26/98 little jerry As a Hollywood attempt to barely scratch the surface of The Final Solution-its impressive. 5 stars
11/25/98 Fred Everyone should see this movie. A masterpiece. 5 stars
10/18/98 Kwyjibo Very hardcore. Anyone who can't feel terrible at what happened after watching this is dead. 5 stars
10/14/98 Chi-Fan Hu One of the best films I've ever seen. I wouldn't usually go and see one of these. 5 stars
9/18/98 Couch Potato Critic A powerful film. One of the 6 best films Spielberg has ever done. 5 stars
9/06/98 Helle Marie Excuse me for saying the first hour was boring, but th rest was fuckin` great! 5 stars
9/04/98 pooky the bald Dare I say this movie had faults? I dare. Important, but lacking energy. 4 stars
9/04/98 Badass The most human movie ever made. 5 stars
8/16/98 {{{OZ}}} Necessary viewing. 5 stars
Note: Duplicate, 'planted,' or other obviously improper comments
will be deleted at our discretion. So don't bother posting 'em. Thanks!
Your Name:
Your Comments:
Your Location: (state/province/country)
Your Rating:

Discuss this movie in our forum

  23-Feb-1997 (R)
  DVD: 09-Mar-2004



Home Reviews  Articles  Release Dates Coming Soon  DVD  Top 20s Criticwatch  Search
Public Forums  Festival Coverage  Contests About Australia's Largest Movie Review Database.
Privacy Policy | HBS Inc. | |   

All data and site design copyright 1997-2017, HBS Entertainment, Inc.
Search for
reviews features movie title writer/director/cast