More in-depth film festival coverage than any other website!
Home Reviews  Articles  Release Dates Coming Soon  DVD  Top 20s Criticwatch  Search
Public Forums  Festival Coverage  Contests About 

Overall Rating

Awesome: 20%
Worth A Look: 5.71%
Average: 8.57%
Pretty Bad40%
Total Crap: 25.71%

3 reviews, 17 user ratings

[] Buy posters from this movie
by Rob Gonsalves

"Beautiful crap."
2 stars

Watching "Joker" belatedly, I understood quite clearly why it got so many Oscar nominations. For what it is, it’s gorgeously assembled, with a ragged jewel of a performance by Joaquin Phoenix at its center. The problem is, well, what it is.

Joker is set in Gotham City (read: New York City when you hate it; Metropolis is New York City when it’s energizing and teeming with good culture) circa 1981, and garbage is rotting on the sidewalks in its saggy tons. Joker got eleven Oscar nods, and it deserves eight of them. The grimy, soul-grinding milieu is realized with all the talent and vision $62.5 million can buy (while we realize that a movie like this not connected to a superhero franchise would have to make do with a fraction of that bankroll), and yet aesthetically the film is built to caress the eye and ear. The first half hour or so, establishing damaged wannabe-comedian Arthur Fleck (Phoenix) and his uncompromising misery, is top-shelf filmcraft.

Unfortunately, there’s still an hour and a half to go, and Joker ends up repeating itself and lap-dancing its same handful of nihilistic points again and again. Even Phoenix eventually runs out of tricks until we can’t distinguish Arthur’s actual behavior from the iconic, narcissistic behavior (that now-famous stairway dance) in his head. We sit and diagnose Arthur: he’s a mama’s boy who suffered childhood abuse that may have rattled his brain to the point that he emits paroxysms of inappropriate laughter. The way Joker ties into the larger Bat-universe is fairly stupid; Bruce Wayne’s moneybags father Thomas (Brett Cullen, replacing Alec Baldwin and essentially doing Alec Baldwin) is an insensitive jerk, a tough-on-crime elitist who calls poor people “clowns” and is running for mayor. How is he connected to Arthur? Well, he is but he isn’t. It’s that kind of candy-ass movie, toying with big plot moves and then rescinding them.

Despite the supporting cast doing more or less what they’re asked — including Robert De Niro as a talk-show host Arthur fixates on — the movie is handed to Phoenix, and he does amazing things with his physique and voice. He commits fearlessly, and it’s a shame that people have to sit through, ultimately, a failure of a movie to see the performance. Phoenix triumphs over the material — who couldn’t? The material seems to have been conceived for him to triumph over it. The talk about Joker’s biting big chunks from Martin Scorsese, specifically Taxi Driver and The King of Comedy, is a little overblown. If anything, Joker shares more DNA with Abel Ferrara’s 1979 Driller Killer, in which the cold reality of the mentally ill being dumped onto the streets due to lack of funding was more disturbing than the gory drill-killings. Same goes here: again, if someone wanted to make a real drama about such issues that had nothing to do with DC Comics, it’d have to be made for couch change. Sadly, it doesn’t much matter that the topic is addressed in a big hit, because it isn’t really addressed so much as made into background.

An army of talent has been marshaled here to fashion a beautiful piece about a pismire. It’s loaded with artistry without itself being art, and the primary reason is that Todd Phillips, its nominal director, isn’t a director. Oh, he knows how to get usable footage for fake-outrageous mainstream comedies like the Hangover trilogy. But he can’t really shape material so that it means something or earns the horrible associations it may dredge up in some viewers, and it keeps backing away from anything truly explosive. Like The Dark Knight Rises, it demonizes protest (what the hell drugs was Michael Moore on when he praised this thing for its politics?) and finally takes no stand. It just takes this rambly, inchoate semi-narrative about a fractured psyche and pushes it out there on a toxic exhaust cloud of irony. I don’t usually pick on movies for violence they may or may not inspire, but Joker is the sort of interiorized, subjective work that doesn’t show Arthur’s life for the rancid squalor it truly would be; it just tries on the kinds of grim and gritty pirouettes and outfits that appeal to real Arthur Flecks.

But, unlike a true work of art (like those two Scorsese classics) that would drive me to its defense, "Joker" is all pose. It says nothing about Arthur or his victims or his brutal world. Nothing.

link directly to this review at
originally posted: 01/23/20 06:07:00
[printer] printer-friendly format  
OFFICIAL SELECTION: 2019 Toronto International Film Festival For more in the 2019 Toronto International Film Festival series, click here.

User Comments

6/28/20 morris campbell great acting thats about it 3 stars
5/14/20 Jack Sommersby The most childishly nihilistic crock since "Fight Club." 1 stars
3/17/20 FUKA TOYOKAWA The actor (Phoenix) performed well, but the deep plot of the pretense was boring. 2 stars
2/07/20 Herald of God Emperor Donald Trump is winning. Peter Sobczynski is crying. 5 stars
1/31/20 Jules McGools One of the most powerful films I’ve seen. I couldn’t stop thinking about it for days 5 stars
1/27/20 Jumbling Jay This movie is spell-binding superb! Phoenix deserves an Oscar 5 stars
1/21/20 Langano Decent film but Phoenix's performance is the reason to watch. 3 stars
12/21/19 BERNARD Scary great. 4 stars
10/17/19 Louise (the real one) Why the hate? A well-made film with a message. Phoenix is excellent. 5 stars
10/14/19 Bob Dog Training film for future psychopaths (Hint: they clap at the end). 1 stars
10/12/19 Gary Anderson “ A modern masterpiece a performance art and technical film craft 4 stars
10/07/19 Ham Bergler I have an incel role model! Next to Hulk Hogan. 3 stars
10/07/19 Action movie fan The years most overrated movie 2 stars
10/06/19 Jack One of the worst movies I have seen in at least 10 years. 1 stars
10/05/19 David Green Simply brilliant. Joachim amazing 5 stars
10/04/19 Go see this movie— don't bring kids! A+ Half drama, half cautionary tale.This movie's great— Peter Sobczynski is full of shit! 5 stars
10/04/19 Bob Dog An astonishing masterwork of the highest calibre and quality, quite incredible. 5 stars
Note: Duplicate, 'planted,' or other obviously improper comments
will be deleted at our discretion. So don't bother posting 'em. Thanks!
Your Name:
Your Comments:
Your Location: (state/province/country)
Your Rating:

Discuss this movie in our forum

  04-Oct-2019 (R)
  DVD: 07-Jan-2020


  DVD: 07-Jan-2020

Home Reviews  Articles  Release Dates Coming Soon  DVD  Top 20s Criticwatch  Search
Public Forums  Festival Coverage  Contests About Australia's Largest Movie Review Database.
Privacy Policy | HBS Inc. | |   

All data and site design copyright 1997-2017, HBS Entertainment, Inc.
Search for
reviews features movie title writer/director/cast